Your Follow-Ups Are Boring—Here’s Why Clients Disappear

Salespeople love to talk about being ghosted. It’s become the go-to excuse when a buyer goes silent. But here’s the hard truth: most of the time, customers aren’t ghosting at all. They just haven’t been given a real reason to keep the conversation going.

Earning the Right to a Response

Customers don’t owe anyone a reply. The burden is on the salesperson to earn that response. If there’s silence, it often means the message simply wasn’t relevant, urgent, or valuable enough to interrupt their day.

“Customers don’t owe you a response. You have to earn the response, and that is where the breakdown occurs.”

Forget the “Just Checking In” Routine

Empty follow-up messages kill momentum. “Just checking in” is not a strategy. Neither are emails asking if the proposal was reviewed or if there are any questions. These are self-serving, and customers know it.

Every follow-up must deliver value. That means sharing a new insight, a timely update, or a relevant question that helps the customer think differently.

“Your follow-up should include at least one of the following: a new insight, a new question, some new information, a customer example, a business issue they may not have considered, a consequence of waiting, a new opportunity.”

Get Specific. Get Personal.

Generic messages get ignored. Specific questions prompt action. Instead of weak asks like, “Any thoughts on this?” try, “When you look at the proposal, which is more important: reducing implementation time or minimizing disruption?”

Pull in the customer’s own words from earlier conversations. Referencing something they shared shows empathy, understanding, and attention to detail.

“Use their words. Go back to the original conversation you had with them. What did the customer tell you?”

Connect to Today’s Business Problems

If a solution doesn’t feel relevant to what’s happening right now, it drops to the bottom of the priority list. The follow-up must tie directly to what the customer is facing in the moment.

Highlight the cost of indecision. Ask, “What happens if you wait another 30 days?” or “How is this delay impacting your customers?” Make the price of inaction real and immediate.

Don’t Dump Information, Instead Spark a Conversation

Follow-ups should be short, sharp, and designed to trigger a reply, never a data dump that lets the customer make a decision without you. Limit emails to three or four sentences. The goal isn’t to educate, it’s to create interest and get a seat at the table.

Show Market Expertise

Bring insights from the wider industry, the customer’s competitors, or recent news. Position yourself as an expert, not just a vendor desperate for a response. When buyers see that level of understanding, they’re far more likely to re-engage.

When To Walk Away

Silence sometimes is the answer. If there’s no response after several meaningful follow-ups, don’t become the salesperson that clogs the inbox with nagging reminders. Know when to go quiet. Save energy for high-value opportunities, and be ready to reconnect when circumstances change.

Test Every Message Before Sending

Before hitting send, pause. Ask, “If I were the customer, would I reply to this?” If the answer is no, rewrite it. Add more insight or a better question. Every message should move the customer forward, not just keep the deal on life support.

Stop accusing customers of ghosting when there’s been no real reason to respond. It’s not about following up, it’s about earning the right to the next conversation.


Mark Hunter :
Is the customer really ghosting you, or did you just simply not give them a reason to get in touch with you? Hey, it’s your fault, not the customer’s. And the show begins right now. You’re listening to the Sales Hunter Podcast with Mark Hunter, where the focus is to help you as a sales leader sell with confidence and integrity. And now here’s your host. Customers don’t owe you a response. They don’t. You have to earn the response, and that is where the breakdown occurs. You see, the customer’s ghosting you because you didn’t give them a reason.

Mark Hunter :
You didn’t earn the response. Too many salespeople label a customer as ghosting when the real issue is there just wasn’t. So hey, let’s get— let’s cut to the chase. Let’s get into it. First of all, let’s stop blaming the customer, okay? Let’s just get that off the table right now. And I know this is how you’re feeling. You’ve had— you maybe have had a great conversation. Maybe they seemed interested.

Mark Hunter :
You sent the proposal, you followed up, you— nothing. You followed up again, nothing, nothing. Hey, come on, they didn’t ghost you. You did not provide the value that they were looking for when they needed it, how they needed it. You see, here’s the question: did they ghost you, or did you not provide them what they’re looking for at that time. You see, here it is. Customer being silent doesn’t necessarily mean they’re not interested. It doesn’t, doesn’t.

Mark Hunter :
It may mean that your message isn’t important enough for them to interrupt their day. You see, you’re not delivering timely value. This is why just checking in is not a sales strategy. I hate that. Every day I get an email from somebody that says, I’m just checking in. Forget it. That’s not what you’re doing. You see, Or saying, oh, I wanted to see if you had any questions, or I wanted to bounce this to the top of your list, circling back, all of those pieces.

Mark Hunter :
What’s missing? It’s value. Okay, here’s the deal. Every one of those messages is asking the customer to do something for you. You need to be asking them, what can you do for them? You see, you’ve got to be giving them an update of value. Instead, what you need to be asking is, what am I giving them that makes responding worthwhile? Okay, now that’s not what you’re asking the customer, but you got to ask yourself this because every follow-up needs a reason. Before you send the follow-up, ask yourself, why would the customer respond to this message today? And this is critical— today. And I’ll unpack this more in a bit. You see, your follow-up should include at least one of the following.

Mark Hunter :
It’s got to be a new insight. It’s got to be a new question. It’s got to be some new information. A customer example, a business issue they may not have considered, a consequence of waiting, a new opportunity. It could be any number of things. But here’s, here’s the thing. Your inquiry to them, your email to them, your message to them needs to be short, 3 to 4 lines. This is absolutely critical.

Mark Hunter :
Now, here’s where I’m going with this. You are trying to provide the customer with enough information to where they’ll respond to you. You see, you don’t want to send them so much information they can make a decision without you. No, what you’re trying to do is you’re trying to spark interest and have them see you as somebody they need to talk to. This is why I say it’s only 3 to 4 sentences, period. Because again, what I’m doing is I’m creating interest. Now, if you’ve gone through this pattern with the customer, you’ve done this half a dozen times, and I’ll dig into more More of this in just a bit. Then yeah, you can start sharing with them more, more information, but not too much more, because again, you’ve got to make sure that you get the conversation.

Mark Hunter :
Your goal is not to educate them without having them talk to you. Now, you see, if you’re not bringing something new to the conversation, don’t expect the customer to bring something new back to you, right? Think about this, right? You want the customer to respond, but you haven’t given them— see, here’s the thing. This is why I say don’t ask, you know, uh, if, if you have any thoughts. You can ask better questions. You know, a weak question is, have you had a chance to review the proposal? They can ignore that. Instead, what you want to ask is something like this: hey, when you look at the proposal, which is more important to you, reducing the implementation time or minimizing disruption? Now, you notice what I did was I asked a question. And framed it around the critical needs. I framed it around timely critical needs.

Mark Hunter :
And this is what’s absolutely— this is where so many salespeople miss out. They may have a very viable solution, very viable option, but if it doesn’t address what the customer is working on right now, it doesn’t work. You see, here’s another good question that you can respond. You mentioned getting this solved before Q4. Is critical. Is that timing still important? See, now I’m asking them for a straight up yes or no, and I’m trying to get clarification on this. And that’s okay. That’s okay.

Mark Hunter :
But what I’m doing is I’m helping them see that I care about your business right now. Here’s another one. What’s the biggest issue keeping this from moving forward? You know, this, and you may have to unpack what this is. Again, I, I’ve done this many, many times. I’ve had solutions that I know I can provide, and I’ve had to stop and ask because, because they’re not responding. What’s the critical issue? And, and they may say, hey, it’s not in the budget for this year, or it’s not fine. That’s okay. But what I’m getting is I’m at least getting them to respond.

Mark Hunter :
Specific questions create responses. Generic questions create silence. This is why I say, hey, any thoughts on this? You know, what’s your view on this? That’s just too generic. I can ask that of them when I’m face-to-face with them on a Teams call, Zoom call, face-to-face, whatever. But I can’t ask that in an email or any kind of a message. No, it just doesn’t work. I’ve got to be very, very specific and dialed into where they’re at. Now, the other piece is I want to use the customer’s own words.

Mark Hunter :
Use their words. Go back to the original conversation you had with them. What did the customer tell you? Your follow-up email may be, may be specifically, you mentioned this, and how is this going to impact this? In other words, you literally play back to them what they shared with you. Now, this is incredibly valuable. In a voicemail because I can demonstrate a little bit of empathy. I can demonstrate a little bit of understanding, but I’m talking more about here in terms of an email. You see, here’s the whole thing. Maybe they said we need to get costs under control, or our team is stretched, we can’t afford another delay, our current supplier.

Mark Hunter :
Okay, so in the follow-up, you can sit there and say, Deb, when we spoke, you mentioned The delays were costing your team nearly a day each week. Has that improved or is it still an issue? Or, hey, how about this one? Deb, when we spoke, you mentioned the delays were costing you a day each week. How is that impacting your customers? In other words, now what I’m doing is I’m referencing something that they shared with you and I’m playing back to them specifically and ask them a question on it. You see, I’m no longer checking in. I’m giving them some insight. Now, you may share with them some insights. You mentioned that this is a critical— this is a delay that’s impacting X, and I see where Y, a competitor, is coming out with something. Yeah.

Mark Hunter :
See, now what I’m doing is I’m not only playing back to them what they shared with me, but I’m building on it. By creating a sense of urgency because I’m understanding what’s happening in the marketplace with a competitor. This is where understanding what’s going on in the marketplace, in the industry that they’re, that they’re playing in, is absolutely critical. Because what you’re doing is you’re, you’re continuing the conversation about their problem and demonstrating to them that you truly know a lot more. That’s absolutely key because The critical issue is they may say, I don’t need to work with you, I can go work with somebody else. But if I can, in my follow-up messages— and again, I got to keep them short, got to keep them tight— demonstrate to them that I understand the industry, I understand their customers, I understand their competitors, this helps separate me from somebody else. Because remember, information has been democratized because of AI. It has.

Mark Hunter :
Everybody has availability to all kinds of information. What I’m trying to get to now is I’m trying to get to where you, the customer, see me as not only having information— it’s been democratized— but I know what to do with it. I can help you with it. This is what’s absolutely key because again, many times the customer has an issue, but they can go someplace else to get it solved. See, you have to be seen as the expert. And this is why I, I love putting in there one sentence of, here’s what I’m seeing elsewhere in the industry. I’m sharing a little bit of my commentary because now what I’m doing is I’m, I’m delivering to them something that begs their response, but I’m also positioning my— me as an expert in their space. That is going to increase the likelihood of them responding to me significantly.

Mark Hunter :
This is why generic responses, generic follow-up messages just don’t cut it. Take a few minutes. You got to craft the message because here’s a— here’s the other thing that you can really play, play in on, and that is make the cost of doing nothing visible for the customer. In other words, Customers don’t always feel urgency because salespeople don’t help them see the cost of waiting. We don’t play that out. I, again, I love doing this. You can ask, what happens if you wait another 30 days? What happens if these orders don’t get shipped? What happens if this expansion doesn’t get done in context of your other initiatives you have going on. You see, what I did there was I tied in what I’m selling in conjunction with a bigger piece of the picture.

Mark Hunter :
And I can find the bigger piece of picture by looking at their annual reports, their quarterly earnings. I look at what’s happening in the industry. You see, what I want to try to do is I want them to see what the cost of the problem is. What’s the problem cost? Many times they don’t fully understand. They don’t fully understand what the cost is. And now this is where stories can come into play. I do not recommend sharing stories in follow-up messages where I’m trying to unghost a customer. No, no, I gotta save that story for when I have them face to face, online, something of that nature.

Mark Hunter :
Then I should— you know, I was working with a company recently, similar industry, That, and, and I can share the story with them of what happens, of what could happen if they don’t respond now. You see, there may be an opportunity cost that they’re missing. There may be an additional risk that they are facing. You see, your follow-up might easily say, when we talked, you estimated this problem was costing you about $10,000 per month. Waiting another quarter is a $30,000 decision. Now, for a lot of companies, $10,000 per month issue is not, not a problem, but it may be $1 million, it may be $2 million, maybe $5 million. See, what I’m looking for is I’m looking for them to see from me enough pain as to how I can help them. When I do that, then there is a reason for them to respond.

Mark Hunter :
See, urgency isn’t created by us, the salesperson, needing the deal. Urgency is not created by us. It’s quarter end, it’s month end, it’s year end. No, that’s not urgency. Urgency comes from the customer understanding the cost, the real cost of not acting. And I’ll tell you what’s interesting. Many times the customer doesn’t really realize this. They are so caught up in their world.

Mark Hunter :
They’re so caught up in all their things that they don’t realize that. Now, you also got to know the customer’s ghosting you. You got to know when to walk away. There are times when you do need to walk away. Yeah. Don’t become the salesperson who’s sending 14 emails every other day saying, just moving this to the top of your inbox. No, that At some point, silence is information. Now, there’s a response that you can send.

Mark Hunter :
I do not like doing this, but I’m going to share it. Then I’m going to share with you what I prefer doing. So you could send, you know, the customer a note. Hey, it looks like this isn’t a priority right now. I’ll close this out on my end. If circumstances change, I’m happy to reconnect. I hate doing that. Now ironically, this oftentimes gets a response.

Mark Hunter :
What I tend to do is I just go silent. I just simply stop sending them messages. Now the length of time is going to be contingent upon the size of the opportunity. In other words, if it’s a small opportunity, I’m not going to chase you very long, but if it’s a big opportunity, I’m going to chase you for a long time. But what I’ll do is make them appoint time When I’ve just gone silent, I’ve gone silent and I’m going to wait until there’s a big opportunity, until big change in news, big— maybe there’s a change in the company, change in something. Then I’ll start reaching out to them again. Remember, the challenge I want to leave you with before you send your next follow-up, stop and ask yourself, if I were the customer, would I respond to this? The answer is no, don’t hit send. Add an insight, ask a better question.

Mark Hunter :
Remember, bring something new. Stop accusing the customer of ghosting you when you haven’t given them a reason to respond. And remember, your job isn’t to follow up. Your job is to move the customer forward. Hey, I’m Marc Hunter of The Sales Center. You’ve been listening to The Sales Center Podcast. My whole goal is to help you see and achieve what you didn’t think was possible. If you’ve got an SKO meeting coming up, reach out.

Mark Hunter :
I want to be part of it. I want to be part of your next sales kickoff meeting because I can come in, I can share with you strategies. And of course, my new book, Integrity First Selling, pick it up. Hey, I’m Marc Haine of The Sales Hunter. Great selling.

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Downloadable Sales Resources

Sales Leader Rules of Engagement

A Mind for Sales: for salespeople feeling stressed out, burned out, and bummed out. If you’re a sales professional, this book is written just for you. Get your mind right and close more deals with this new business development book.

Subscribe Now

Subscibe to The Sales Hunter Email list to get the latest posts and exclusive sales content right in your inbox.

The Sales Hunter Podcast

The Sales Hunter Podcast features Mark Hunter and top sales leaders, delivering actionable insights to help you become the salesperson you’re meant to be. This show isn’t just for entertainment—it’s designed to empower you with strategies to turn prospects into profits. Subscribe, leave a review, and start selling with confidence!

The Sales Hunter University

The Sales Hunter University offers top-tier sales training available in real-time or on-demand, accessible on any device. Named a Top 10 Sales Development Program in 2022, it’s perfect for sales teams, managers, and driven individuals. Each course is expertly designed by Mark Hunter to deliver the results you need.

Sales Logic Podcast

Ready to amplify your sales impact?

Hosted by sales experts Mark Hunter and Meridith Elliott Powell, Sales Logic answers today’s toughest selling questions with a logic that will help you win more deals and make more money.

When you sell with confidence and integrity, uncertainty becomes your competitive advantage and the sale becomes logical.

The Ultimate Email Prospecting Guide - Mark "The Sales Hunter" Hunter

Download the Ultimate Email Prospecting Guide today!

Enter your information and we’ll immediately send you our most popular download, and add you to our weekly Sales Tip newsletter.