Gut Check Time: How to Evaluate Your Selling Approach

Every salesperson faces one make-or-break question: Would you actually buy from you? It’s one of the toughest gut checks in sales, and there’s no hiding from the answer. It forces a hard look at how value is delivered, how trust is built, and whether each touchpoint drives real outcomes for customers.

Here’s how to put that test into practice and why it matters more than any script or technique.

1. Flip the Script: Become Your Own Customer

Would those prospecting emails grab your attention?

Would that voicemail make you call back?

Most sales outreach falls flat because it’s focused on the seller, not the buyer. Offers built on “let me tell you about us” never stand out. Customers aren’t looking for another presentation or a laundry list of features. They want someone who sees their world and brings something new to the table.

“You don’t earn the meeting because you want the meeting. You earn it because the customer sees value in having the conversation.”

Evaluate every customer interaction by asking: Am I delivering insight or just asking for time? Does the message create curiosity that makes people want to respond now? If not, go back to the drawing board.

2. Questions Separate the Pros from the Average

Average sellers interrogate customers with qualifying questions just to get to the pitch. The best salespeople ask questions that make customers pause and think. They dig for insights that shift perspective, not just information that checks a box.

Want better conversations? Ask questions that help customers think differently about their business, and be ready to follow where those conversations go. That’s when selling stops feeling transactional and starts feeling relevant.

3. Sell Outcomes, Not Hype

Every salesperson claims to offer “great service.” That doesn’t move the needle. The real question is: What changes for customers because they bought from you? Can you articulate the ROI, not in your words, but in outcomes customers believe they’ll actually receive?

“Value isn’t what you say you provide. Value is the outcome the customer believes, perceives they will receive.”

It comes down to this: If you can’t explain why someone should pay more for your solution, don’t be surprised when they won’t.

4. Anchor Everything on Trust

Trust doesn’t get built by simply saying “trust me.” It takes consistent actions: following through, admitting when you don’t know, putting the buyer’s long-term priorities ahead of short-term commission. When a solution isn’t right for the customer, say so. That’s where integrity shows up.

Long-term sellers play the long game because it’s the only game that lasts.

5. Hold the Line on Price

Confidence in your price equals confidence in your outcomes. If you’d hesitate to pay your own rate, that signals you don’t believe in the value you’re offering. Too many salespeople roll over the moment price pressure hits, offering discounts before a customer even objects. The price should reflect real outcomes, and it should hold up under scrutiny.

“If you don’t believe you’re worth the price, why should the customer?”

Calculate and communicate ROI in every offer. Don’t apologize for your price. Own it.

6. Every Interaction Should Open the Next Conversation

Radio silence happens for one reason: nothing valuable was left on the table in the last conversation. Every interaction should deliver insight, plant an idea, or challenge the customer to see things differently. That’s what keeps the relationship moving and follow-ups feeling valuable instead of feeling like pestering.

The ultimate test: If you received your own follow-up, would you look forward to hearing from you again?

The Weekly Sales Hunter Challenge

Preparation starts on the inside. Before every sales call, flip the situation and sit on the other side of your pitch:

  1. Would you want to talk to you?
  2. Would you trust you?
  3. Would you pay your price?

If the answer to any of these is “no,” go back and fix it. This isn’t a technique, it’s the mirror every great salesperson stares into.

Mindset. Value. Confidence. Convenience. It starts with focusing on the customer’s outcomes, working from their needs, and delivering confidence in both yourself and your offer. That’s how lasting customer relationships and consistently strong results are built.

Ready for a gut check? Step into your customer’s shoes, and let the truth drive change. The salespeople who do will always stand out and win more, for the right reasons.


Mark Hunter :
Would you buy from you? Hey, it’s gut check time because let me tell you something. If you were sitting across the table from you, would you buy from you? Would you respond to your own email? Would you respond to your phone call? That’s the topic. Let’s get real and have a gut check. And the show begins right now.

Speaker B :
You’re listening to the Sales Hunter Podcast with Marc Hunter, where the focus is to help you as a sales leader sell with confidence and integrity. And now, here’s your host.

Mark Hunter :
Hey, today I want to evaluate you. I want— really, I want us to evaluate ourselves because I’ll tell you what, would you return your own prospecting call? Would you respond to your own email? Would you trust the questions that you ask? Would you go radio silent on yourself if you were being sold by you? You see, here’s the whole thing. I want to ask you a series of questions. I want you to be very candid. Would you respond to your own prospecting? Yeah. I want you to look at your prospecting from customer side. If you receive the email that you sent yesterday, would you respond? Too much prospecting sounds like, I want 20 minutes of your time. Hey, I want to bounce this to the top.

Mark Hunter :
We’ve been in business for 30 years. We can do this, this, this, this. To hold it, hold it, hold it, hold it. You got to be talking about the difference between being interested versus being interested, interested in the customer. You see, questions that you can throw out: does any message demonstrate that I understand something about them? Have I personalized it to them by any means? Am I bringing an idea or merely asking for time? If I’m asking for time, I better be bringing an idea. Is there a reason for them to respond now? Am I creating curiosity? You see, you don’t earn the meeting because you want the meeting. You earn the meeting because the customer sees value in having the conversation. I want— let’s run through that again.

Mark Hunter :
You don’t earn the meeting because you want the meeting. You earn it because the customer sees value in having the conversation. You see, would you enjoy having a conversation with yourself? Yeah, yeah. Hey, let me tell you about our company. We’ve been in business for 47 years. We have 38 locations. Here’s our 32-slide PowerPoint. Who cares? Customers don’t want another presentation.

Mark Hunter :
I don’t care how it comes to them. They don’t want it. They want someone who understands their world. Ask yourself this question. How much are you talking versus asking? And more importantly, how good are your questions? See, average salespeople love to ask questions to qualify, but they ask lame questions because they try to almost goat the customer into coming up with an answer. And goat is not the greatest of all time. Goat is to— you’re trying to jab them in the rear. See, great salespeople ask questions that cause customers to think differently.

Mark Hunter :
That’s a major distinction. Great salespeople ask customers questions that the customer can’t answer and the salesperson That’s a big difference because what that means is that now you have a conversation. Here’s another one. Would you believe your own value proposition? This connects beautifully to my book, Integrity First Selling, because here’s the whole thing. A salesperson will sit there and say, we provide outstanding service. Really? So does everyone else. I mean, come on, come on. We care about our customers.

Mark Hunter :
Who doesn’t claim that? See, if you were a customer, would what you’re saying justify paying more? Stop and think about that. Value isn’t what you say you provide. Value is the outcome the customer believes, perceives they will receive. Big difference there. So instead of talking about features and capabilities, move toward what changes for the customer because they bought from you. Big problem. And I’m going to unpack this in future episodes about when do you put benefits on the table. Because there’s a problem.

Mark Hunter :
Too many salespeople are putting benefits on the table way too early. So, here’s the question. What changes for the customer because they bought from you? Will they make more money? Will they save time? Will they reduce risk? Will they avoid a headache? Will they improve productivity? Will they decrease turnover? Will they have less churn of customers? Will they grow faster, serve their customers better? Whole IC. If you can’t explain why you pay more for you, don’t be surprised when your customer won’t. Here’s another question for you. Would you trust you? Yeah, that’s the whole premise of my book, Integrity First Selling. Yeah, I’ll take a cheesy plug for right now. Pick it up if you haven’t bought it.

Mark Hunter :
Read it. Trust isn’t created by telling customers, trust me. That’s easy. That’s a throwaway. It’s created by behavior. It’s created by behavior. Now think about what is behavior. Behavior is not what is said.

Mark Hunter :
Behavior is what’s done behind the words that are said. Would you trust a salesperson who behaved the way you do? No wonder politicians have such a low trust factor. Yeah. Do you tell customers what they need to hear? Even when it might cost you the sale? Whoa. Do you admit when you don’t know something? Do you follow through when you say you will? Do you tell them when your solution isn’t the right solution? See, do you put their long-term interest ahead of your short-term commission? If, if you’re not playing the long game, you shouldn’t be in sales. The real test of integrity isn’t what you do when your interests And your customer’s interests align. No, that’s not the real test of integrity. It’s what happens when they don’t.

Mark Hunter :
Think about that. You see, it’s easy to have integrity and all that sort of stuff when you and your customers have the same interests and everything aligns. Integrity really comes out when they’re not. See, this is why integrity is so important. ‘Cause it allows you to be truthful with your customer. Hey, here’s another one. Would you pay your own price? Yeah. Yeah, because you want your customer to have confidence in your price, right? But do you have confidence in your price? It is amazing.

Mark Hunter :
It is amazing at how people roll over and play dead when it comes to price. And so stop and think about this. If you don’t believe in your own price, that means you don’t believe in the outcomes you create. And if you don’t believe in the outcomes you create, Why are you even selling? See, salespeople reveal doubt on so many levels when they sit there and say, I know we’re a little more expensive. Let, or let me see what I can do with this price. Maybe I can sharpen the pencil and we can change some things around. I might be able to get you a better number. And the customer hasn’t even objected yet.

Mark Hunter :
Because that’s oftentimes what happens. See, I say that too many discounts are given because the salesperson doesn’t believe in the price that are given based on the demands of the customer. See, if you don’t believe you’re worth the price, why should the customer? You see, price and confidence go hand in hand, and they translate back to value. Now, confidence does not mean arrogance, but I’ll tell you what, If you don’t buy from you, if you won’t buy from you, there is no way that your customer will buy from you. And there’s no way that you can say that if you’re confident. You see, confidence means that you understand the value you create. You understand the outcome, the need, and you believe that the price is fair for that outcome because you’ve aligned the price with the outcome. You see, there’s an ROI.

Mark Hunter :
I believe in my price because I have computed an ROI, return on investment, that the customer’s going to receive from working with me. So I have absolute confidence from knowing what sits behind the price. So I don’t have to apologize for it. This is what you have to see. You have to have incredible confidence. I’m going to give you a formula when we get down here to the end here today. And I want you to put it into practice. Here’s a question for you.

Mark Hunter :
Would you want to hear from you again? Yeah. How many times have you had customers go radio silent on you? Yeah. I love this as kind of the final test because salespeople spend enormous amounts of time worrying about follow-up. You know, they’re ghosting me. They’ve gone radio silent. They’re, you know, clearly something’s gone wrong, something, yada, yada, yada. Hold it. Hold it.

Mark Hunter :
Hold it. Did you give them a reason to want to hear from you again? Did you give them a reason for them to respond to you? You see, every interaction needs to leave something behind— an idea, an insight, a question, a challenge, a different way of looking at their business— and it has to be all articulated around their primary objectives that they need to get accomplished. This is the difference between interest and intent. See, so many salespeople say, oh, I, I love what I sell, I love what I sell, it’s so valuable. Yeah, but what you’re selling is what people are interested in, but there’s no intent. You see, you want customers thinking this: every time I talk with Marc, I get something useful. That’s when follow-ups start— stops feeling like follow-up. Now you’re creating conversations.

Mark Hunter :
The customer actually values. Does the customer remember a conversation with you 2 days after they’ve had it? This really comes back to the whole title for the episode today, Would You Buy From You? And you’ve got to tell— here’s some basic fundamentals that you’ve got to put into practice. Don’t answer that question too quickly. Don’t answer, don’t answer that question, you know, would you buy from you, too quickly. What I want you to do is I want you this week to become your own customer. I want you this week become your own customer. I want you to read your prospecting mails, your prospecting emails. I want you to listen to yourself on a sales call.

Mark Hunter :
I hope you got Gong or Course or something like that, and you’re recording your calls. Look at your presentation. Is the presentation about you or is about the customer’s needs? Yeah. I want you to review your follow-up. Is your, is your follow-up just merely stating things or is it creating a significant call to action that’s of value for the customer? Now think about how you present your price and ask yourself, if I didn’t know me, would I buy from me? The answer is yes. Great. But more important, the question you have to ask yourself is, how confident are you in presenting your price? A lot of salespeople are confident in the sales call. They are.

Mark Hunter :
They’re just confident people. But when it comes to price, when it comes to putting the offer on the table, they roll over like a cheap flower that just wilts. Yeah. You see, your whole objective here is to be able to present your price with confidence because you’ve uncovered the need. You’ve created urgency, the customer’s urgency, and you know that what you’re going to do is going to help them achieve X. So you can state the price confidently. In fact, I say you don’t ask the customer for the price. You don’t tell them— well, let me put it this way.

Mark Hunter :
You tell them because what you’re doing is you’re saying, It’s investing. You are looking for them to invest in you because here’s the whole thing. If you don’t believe in yourself, your customers won’t. Now, I said I was going to give you a formula, and here’s a very cool formula that I want you to take to the bank. It starts with mindset, your mindset. This is why I want you to be listening to this, this episode and previous, previous episodes. You gotta have the right mindset to be focused on how you can help the customer. ‘Cause when you do that, now I can uncover a better value proposition.

Mark Hunter :
And I uncover the better value proposition because I’m having a better conversation with the customer. They’re engaged with me, I’m engaged with them. And what’s coming out of it is a level of confidence. The confidence cuts both ways. You are more confident with them and they’re more confident with you. You see, mindset Value prop, confidence, convenience. Where’s convenience come into play? This isn’t a convenience store, is it? No, but it’s convenient for the customer to do business with you. Now, what have you done? You’ve created a partner.

Mark Hunter :
You’ve created a partner because they see value, absolute value in working with you. Well, I’m going to go back to it again. Mindset, What’s your mindset? And your mindset has to be focused around the fact that you are serving customers. It’s not what you sell. It’s not your commission. It’s not your annual numbers. It’s not any— your mindset is around how you can help others succeed. How are you going to help your customers succeed? How are you going to help your customers serve their customers better? If you’re in B2C, it’s how you’re helping your customers live a better life.

Mark Hunter :
Achieve their goals, whatever it might be. But see, it’s, it’s goal KPI, it’s outcome focused. And what that does is that’s gonna, that’s gonna allow you to understand a better value prop. You’re gonna be able to create a better value prop because they’re gonna be able to share with you, they’re gonna be comfortable sharing with you the critical needs that they have. And when you create a better value prop, wow, there’s value in it. There’s value in it for the customers, value in it for you, because now you’ve upped your mindset. And so what does this do? It creates that level of confidence. You have this level of confidence that you feel really good about what it is that you’re selling, and your customer has a lot of confidence in you.

Mark Hunter :
And that ultimately creates convenience— convenience in having the sale go through. And remember, we don’t close a deal, but we open a relationship. Here’s what I’m going to refer to as the Sales Hunter Challenge for this week. Okay. Before your next sales call, take 5 minutes and pretend you’re the customer. Look at, look at everything you’re going to be sharing from their side of the table. Ask yourself 3 questions. Would I want to talk with me? What’s the value that this person’s bringing that I can’t get from somebody else? 2, would I trust me? In other words, why should the customer trust me? Because Am I with a company that’s reputable? Do I have great social media cred? Do I have referrals? Do I have recommendations? In other words, where’s that level of trust? And 3, would I pay my price? Would I pay my price? In other words, when I get through with this sales process and ultimately work to secure a deal, is the price going to be one that I can buy into? If you can’t answer yes to all 3 of these, You got to fix that before the next sales call.

Mark Hunter :
You see, here, here, here’s what it comes down to. Would you buy from you isn’t a sales technique question. It’s a mirror. And almost every salesperson listening right now, watching, can find something they need to improve. Hey, I love delivering this podcast to you. You know, we’re going to a new format, one episode a week, one with me delivering a very key topic, just like what we’re doing here today, in about a 15-minute format once a week. Once a week. Because I want to help you become the salesperson that I know you’re capable of doing.

Mark Hunter :
Hey, if you’ve got a sales kickoff meeting coming up, I want you to reach out to me. I’ve got open dates on my calendar. I want you to reach out to me. Let’s— I want to be part of your sales kickoff meeting. Maybe it’s not a formal SKO, but it’s just some sort of meeting that you’re getting your salespeople to get. Call me. Let’s go. I want to come in.

Mark Hunter :
I want to talk with— I want to be part of it because I’m going to help you get your numbers to the next, to a higher level for the next year. And remember, the Sales Hunter podcast comes to you every week. Make sure you subscribe to it and share it with your fellow salespeople. Hey, I’m Marc Hunter, the Sales Hunter. Great selling.

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Downloadable Sales Resources

The Integrity Checklist

A Mind for Sales: for salespeople feeling stressed out, burned out, and bummed out. If you’re a sales professional, this book is written just for you. Get your mind right and close more deals with this new business development book.

Subscribe Now

Subscibe to The Sales Hunter Email list to get the latest posts and exclusive sales content right in your inbox.

The Sales Hunter Podcast

The Sales Hunter Podcast features Mark Hunter and top sales leaders, delivering actionable insights to help you become the salesperson you’re meant to be. This show isn’t just for entertainment—it’s designed to empower you with strategies to turn prospects into profits. Subscribe, leave a review, and start selling with confidence!

The Sales Hunter University

The Sales Hunter University offers top-tier sales training available in real-time or on-demand, accessible on any device. Named a Top 10 Sales Development Program in 2022, it’s perfect for sales teams, managers, and driven individuals. Each course is expertly designed by Mark Hunter to deliver the results you need.

Sales Logic Podcast

Ready to amplify your sales impact?

Hosted by sales experts Mark Hunter and Meridith Elliott Powell, Sales Logic answers today’s toughest selling questions with a logic that will help you win more deals and make more money.

When you sell with confidence and integrity, uncertainty becomes your competitive advantage and the sale becomes logical.

The Ultimate Email Prospecting Guide - Mark "The Sales Hunter" Hunter

Download the Ultimate Email Prospecting Guide today!

Enter your information and we’ll immediately send you our most popular download, and add you to our weekly Sales Tip newsletter.