3 Fatal Mistakes When Email Prospecting

What would it mean to you or your company, in real dollars, if the prospecting emails you’ve sent turned into customers?

It’s hard to have your email stand out when there are 89 BILLION business emails sent every day!

Now think of your ideal customer. You are sending them emails and so are your competitors, along with their colleagues, bosses, customers, friends, family members, blog sites, and favorite stores.

Many of these emails don’t get opened, and those that do get deleted in just a couple of seconds.

Want to know why?

There are three fatal mistakes most people make when email prospecting:

Mistake 1: Subject Line

With inboxes overflowing with email, your critical mission is to write a subject line that is concise and relevant to the prospect.  A subject line should never be about you or your offering. It needs to catch their attention, whether it be about their business, their role, a colleague, etc.

Also, every character counts…literally!  The maximum number of characters should be no greater than 50 but ideally 25 to leverage mobile users.

Mistake 2: What You Say

If you are lucky enough to have the recipient open your email, you better grab their attention.

I can’t tell you how many emails I get every day where people tell me how great they are and how they can help me.  Really?! I’m thinking to myself, “We haven’t even met and you are telling me how to improve my business?”

The purpose of your email is to engage them, not sell them.  You must be relevant to their business or role and show them you are a thought leader worthy of their time.

Mistake 3: Way Too Long

The third issue is that most emails are way too long.  If you haven’t noticed, most people are over extended and don’t have the time to read a lengthy email — especially from a stranger.

A rule to live by is a prospecting email should never be more than 80 to 100 words.   While you may think there is no way you can say everything you need to say in so few words, I’m here to tell you that you can.  In fact, the less you say, the more likely you will get a response!

If you are looking to leverage email more effectively in your prospecting, let us know if we can help!  We work with companies training them how to write successful emails, and we would be happy to help you. 

Guest post written by Beth Mastre, Vice President Strategic Development for The Sales Hunter.  For the past 20+ years, Beth has honed her email marketing skills, not only out of sheer necessity, but also because she is passionate about connecting with people and helping them succeed.  Beth’s experience and knowledge on this topic is truly second to none.  Her experience is invaluable to The Sales Hunter and to other clients who look to her for guidance and advice. 

YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN An Example of a Bad Email Transformed

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Downloadable Sales Resources

9 Attributes of a Great Sales Leader

A Mind for Sales: for salespeople feeling stressed out, burned out, and bummed out. If you’re a sales professional, this book is written just for you. Get your mind right and close more deals with this new business development book.

Subscribe Now

Subscibe to The Sales Hunter Email list to get the latest posts and exclusive sales content right in your inbox.

The Sales Hunter Podcast

The Sales Hunter Podcast features Mark Hunter and top sales leaders, delivering actionable insights to help you become the salesperson you’re meant to be. This show isn’t just for entertainment—it’s designed to empower you with strategies to turn prospects into profits. Subscribe, leave a review, and start selling with confidence!

The Sales Hunter University

The Sales Hunter University offers top-tier sales training available in real-time or on-demand, accessible on any device. Named a Top 10 Sales Development Program in 2022, it’s perfect for sales teams, managers, and driven individuals. Each course is expertly designed by Mark Hunter to deliver the results you need.

Sales Logic Podcast

Ready to amplify your sales impact?

Hosted by sales experts Mark Hunter and Meridith Elliott Powell, Sales Logic answers today’s toughest selling questions with a logic that will help you win more deals and make more money.

When you sell with confidence and integrity, uncertainty becomes your competitive advantage and the sale becomes logical.

The Ultimate Email Prospecting Guide - Mark "The Sales Hunter" Hunter

Download the Ultimate Email Prospecting Guide today!

Enter your information and we’ll immediately send you our most popular download, and add you to our weekly Sales Tip newsletter.